Benvenuto Pizza Restaurant in Mahopac

Went to pick up order for someone, pizza was good but wings were disgusting and since I didn’t place the order I didn’t know the prices. Found out I was over charged!

Love the food from Benvenuto's. Always fresh and delicious!

Found this restaurant several years ago when traveling back home. Come here every once in a while two hours away for a date night weekend with my wife. Food and services is outstanding , and prices are so reasonable see you soon. Staff is the best

The food was good to people in nice

We were the only table in the restaurant and it took a long while to even order our food. The pizza was very doughy, not cooked very well. The sauce was very sweet and oily. It left oily orange residue , which I have never seen before. My wife is a chef and that's just not how pizza is.

Tim makes a Delicious Pizza, had it twice already. Extremely courteous staff, caring and helpful. We finally have a great restaurant in Mohegan Lake, easy to get to, with great tasting Dishes at terrific Prices.

Cozy and comfortable, delicious food, but most of all, the environment was so wonderful with our two young children. The intimate dining room was almost full yet every other customer was either passive or engaged with our little ones. The staff surely set this expectation as they were the best I have ever encountered as a collective whole, 3 waitstaff assisted us in tandem were thoughtful, interactive, and swift. The owner greeted everyone and was very friendly. My only request would be for a baby changing table in the bathroom. We are from out of town and passing through will but will certainly return soon.

Real deal authentic Italian food. Good ish!

Awesome. Family place that is delicious, you feel appreciated. Great local business. Would go again and again

Always a great time! Friendly staff fantastic food and enormous servings!

Awesome food and great service in a family friendly atmosphere. My favorite Italian restaurant. My family and I have never had an experience short of excellent. So impressed with the food and service through the years that we had our son's communion party there and it was great.

Great food, large portions. Friendly service (but small tables 😂

Get the Grandma slice, so delicious!

No complaints until Friday 8/7. Improper use of face mask on one employee and no mask on another. Unacceptable when serving food to the public.

This spot sure knows how to serve their customers. Constantly with a helpful approach. The food is reasonably priced, constantly fresh and clean.

Very friendly staff and delicious pizza

Service and food was impeccable as usual.

Passing through after a long travel day and this was amazing! Delicious food, superb service and a cozy atmosphere. Definitely recommend it and would love to come again. Thank you for a memorable experience!

I've only tried the food a couple of times, but it was great. Penne ala Vodka was really good. Calzones are awesome. House dressing and the salad was great. Pizza was really good too...

Fantastic local Italian restaurant. On the menu is Linguine in white clam sauce, my favorite meal to try when visiting restaurants for the first time. I have had many plates of this dish in restaurants and home made. I must say Benvenuto makes the best I ever had anywhere. That really means something since I am a world traveler.If you are in town this is a must visit for those who love to eat fantastic foods.

90% satisfied with this go to place. 1 time dissatisfied with order. It happens. Won’t stop me from coming back.

Super tasty food.. quick and respectful service.. what can you not love

All I've tried was their pizza, which was really good.

Good flavor, great pizza. The buffalo chicken pie is amazing and packs a good punch of ‘spicy’. I love it and they delivered hot food within minutes. Very impressed! They have earned my business and will continue to order from Benvenuto!

Stopped in for a quick bite since I'm traveling up here with my friend... Delicious! Great customer service too. Definitely the best pizza spot I've been to in years. I would drive up 8 hours again for this food and service!

Great food..love this place

Hidden Gem that knows how to make real pasta

Still fantastic. Service is solid. Food is priced good and portions are big.

First time trying them today...had the Emigliana Thin Crust Pizza Pie, the Pollo Rollatini and the Zuppa di Pesce with a white sauce - OUTSTANDING! So very delicious! Until we can dine in - I look forward to most definitely trying more items from their menu as I plan to continue ordering from them!

Amazing pizza and food!

Wow. What a great road trip find!

Delicious BBQ chicken slice and the chicken scarpariello pizza is so good!

Best pizza around with family like atmosphere. Great service

The funghi pizza is something I dream about from 3500 miles away. Will get this Everytime I visit the area. The crust is perfect, the toppings generous, and it's a flavor bomb in your mouth.

Friendly, attentive service, High quality food! Oven fired pizza was perfect, the flounder was top notch. Highly recommended!!!!

Great food and great people. My family and I have been coming to Benvenutos for over 3 years. Typically 2-3 times per week. Always a great experience. Food is good quality and prices are very reasonable. Would highly recommend.